Index of Related Posts
Update: Oracle Acknowledges Software Defect
During the development of this study, Oracle’s Product Manager in charge of the In-Memory feature has cited Bug #19308780 as it relates to my findings. I need to point out, however, that it wasn’t until this blog installment that the defective functionality was acknowledged as a bug. Further, the bug being cited is not visible to customers so there is no closure. How can one have closure without knowing what, specifically, is acknowledged as defective? Also read more at The Register: Click here.
Other Blog Updates
Please note, there are blog updates at the end of this article.
How Do I Feel About Oracle Database 12c Release 126.96.36.199?
My very first words on Oracle Database 12c Release 188.8.131.52 can be summed up in a single quotable quote:
This release is hugely important.
I’ve received a lot of email from folks asking me to comment on the freshly released In-Memory Database Option. These words are so overused. This post, however, is about much more than word games. Please read on…
When querying the dba_feature_usage_statistics view the option is known as “In-Memory Column Store.” On the other hand, I’ve read a paper on oracle.com that refers to it as the “In-Memory Option” as per this screen shot:
A Little In-Memory Here, A Little In-Memory There
None of us can forget the era when Oracle referred to the flash storage in Exadata as a “Database In-Memory” platform. I wrote about all that in a post you can view here: click this. But I’m not blogging about any of that. Nonetheless, I remained confused about the option/feature this morning as I was waiting for my download of Oracle Database 12c Release 184.108.40.206 to complete. So, I spent a little time trying to cut through the fog and get some more information about the In-Memory Option. My first play was to search for the term in the search bar at oracle.com. The following screen shot shows the detritus oracle.com returned due to the historical misuse and term overload–but, please, remember that I’m not blogging about any of that:
As the screenshot shows one must eyeball their way down through 8 higher-ranking search results that have nothing to do with this very important new feature before one gets to a couple of obscure blog links. All this term overload and search failure monkey-business is annoying, yes, but I’m not blogging about any of that.
What Am I Blogging About?
This is part I in a short series about Oracle licensing ramifications of the In-Memory Option/In-Memory Column Store Feature.
The very first thing I did after installing the software was to invoke the SLOB database create scripts to quickly get me on my way. The following screen shot shows how I discovered that the separately-licensed In-Memory query feature is enabled by default. If there is any confusion over my use of the word enabled, please click here for a screenshot of Oracle documentation on the parameter. And now, the screen shot showing the default in an instance of the database:
Now, this is no huge red flag because separately-licensed features like Real Application Clusters and Partitioning are sort of “on” by default. This fact about RAC and Partitioning doesn’t bother me because a) one can simply unlink RAC to be safe from accidental usage and b) everyone that uses Enterprise Edition uses the Partitioning Option (I am correct on that assertion, right?). However, I think things are a little different with the In-Memory Option/In-Memory Column Store feature since it is “on” by default and a simple command like the one in the following screen shot means your next license audit will be, um, more entertaining.
OK, please let me point out that I’m trying as hard as I can to not make a mountain out of a mole-hill. I started this post by stating my true feelings about this release. This release is, indeed, hugely important. That said, I do not believe for a second that every Enterprise Edition deployment of Oracle Database 12c Release 220.127.116.11 will need to have the In-Memory Option/In-Memory Column Store Feature in the shopping cart–much unlike Partitioning for example. Given the crushing cost of this option/feature I expect that its use will be very selective. It’s for this reason I wanted to draw to people’s attention the fact that–in my assessment–this option/feature is very easy to use “accidentally.” It really should have a default initialization setting that renders the option/feature more dormant–but the reality is quite the opposite as I will show in Part II. (BLOG UPDATE 2014.07.26: Many Oracle separately licensed features are enabled by default but users actually have to “use” the feature to trigger feature usage as would show up in an audit. Please see Part II where I show that registered usage of this feature happens even if one doesn’t “use” the feature.)
I have to make this post short and relegate it to part I in a series because I can’t yet take it to the next level which is to write about monitoring the feature usage. Why? Well, as I tweeted earlier today, the scripts most widely used for monitoring feature usage are out of date because they don’t (yet) report on the In-Memory Column Store feature. The scripts I allude to are widely known by Google search as MOS 1317265.1. Once these are updated to report usage of the In-Memory Option/In-Memory Column Store Feature I’ll post part II in the series.
Please click on the following link to view Part II in this series: Link to Part II.
BLOG UPDATE 2014.07.29: As you read this please bear in mind the words in this tweet issued by Oracle’s Maria Colgan and consider whether I am saying you “don’t have 2 [sic] do anything” to trigger feature usage. You’ll find that I am saying the opposite in this post. The point is, however, the feature ships ready for you to do this. The feature is enabled by default as per Oracle’s spokesman as reported by informationweek.com and my example herein merely corroborates the spokesman’s assertion.
BLOG UPDATE 2014.07.28: Please don’t forget to view this post (click here) with clear proof that neither the INMEMORY_SIZE nor INMEMORY_QUERY initialization parameters prevent triggering usage of the In-Memory feature.
BLOG UPDATE 2014.07.28: Here is a link to an Informationweek.com article as of 26 July 2014. In the comment section the author quotes an Oracle spokesman as saying “Yes, Oracle Database In-Memory is an option and it is on by default, as have been all new options since Oracle Database 11g.” : Link to 26 July version of Informationweek.com article. Other supporting links: Screenshot 1, Screenshot 2, Screenshot 3, PDF of 26 July 2014 Informationweek article,
BLOG UPDATE 2014.07.25: There is now a Part II posting available in this series. Link to Part II.